Insights

Mismatched Management: Why Skill Gaps in UK Line-Managers Are Driving Talent to Look Elsewhere – and 4 Ways to Fix It

15% of staff are actively job-hunting, but throw a poor manager into the mix and that figure rockets to 45%.

Mismatched Management: Why Skill Gaps in UK Line-Managers Are Driving Talent to Look Elsewhere – and 4 Ways to Fix It Featured Image

The 40 % wake-up call

40% of UK office workers believe their managers don’t have the training or skills they need. That’s not just a grumble around the coffee machine – that’s three million people telling us something’s broken.

 

Hard skills vs. soft truths 

What managers think:

87% feel prepared – yet a third still say they need to sharpen core skills like delegation, feedback loops and organisation.

 

What teams experience:

Only 57% agree their manager is prepared. What they crave are soft skills:

  • Listening (32%)
  • Genuine motivation (30%)
  • Absolute confidentiality (27%)

The reality:
We’re training managers from spreadsheets, not for people.

The retention risk no one’s measuring
The Formula’s annual Insight research found that across the full NI workforce, 15% of staff are actively job-hunting. But throw a poor manager into the mix and that figure rockets to 45%. Another 43% are ‘open to offers’.

In short: one awkward one-to-one, and your attrition risk triples.

Four fixes you can start this quarter

1. Audit the Manager Journey

Why it matters:
You need to understand where capability gaps exist to support manager growth.

Quick win:
Run a “stop-start-continue” survey with managers and their teams, then compare the responses to identify misalignments and improvement areas.

2. Blend Hard-Skill Micro-Learning with Soft-Skill Coaching

Why it matters:
Skill gaps aren’t binary. Micro-learning helps with delegation and organization, while coaching builds empathy and interpersonal strength.

Quick win:
Pair each new manager with a peer coach for 3 months. Use quality of feedback scores to measure progress.

3. Normalise Radical Candour

Why it matters:
Psychological safety increases when managers respect confidentiality and give honest, constructive feedback.

Quick win:
Pilot “Listening Office Hours” where managers ask only questions — no judgments, no decisions — to build trust and openness.

4. Tie Progress to Real Metrics

Why it matters:
Training time means little without outcomes. Focus on attrition, ENPS (Employee Net Promoter Score), and internal mobility instead.

Quick win:
Start with team-level ENPS and set a goal of +10 point improvement by year-end.

So, what’s your next move?

Great managers don’t just happen. They’re designed, iterated and supported – just like any other product you’d stake your business on.

If you’re ready to close the skills gap (and stop bleeding talent), let’s build a management programme that actually sticks. Get in touch.


Mismatched Management: Why Skill Gaps in UK Line-Managers Are Driving Talent to Look Elsewhere – and 4 Ways to Fix It

Valerie Ludlow